Spot Welding

Questions and Answers

In order to set up a machine or process to make good resistance welds many steps must be taken. They begin at machine installation and continue through the day-to-day operation. A good source for the installation information is:

AWS J1.2 “Guide to Installation and Maintenance of Resistance Welding Machines”
This document outlines the many basic specifications for air, water and electrical specifications. After these are established then one turns to the machine components:

MOUNTING SURFACES – Musts be electrically clean, perpendicular or parallel

ELECTRICAL CONNECTIONS – Clean and tight.

HOLDERS – Must be in good serviceable condition with good clean tapers

ELECTRODES – TAPERS AND FACES Must be in good conditions and proper size and not damaged with water tubes in the proper location.

WATER FLOW – Test water flow to all components

WATER TUBE LOCATION CONDITION – Check for electrode AWS J1.2

CYLINDER/SERVO MOTION FORCE DELIVERY- Evaluate force system with force gauge to confirm accuracy and watch for uneven motion or slow followup. Immediate followup is imperative for projection welding.

Nickel can be resistance welded. The question here is: can foil be handled and equipment sized to process it? The answer is - probably, yes. Equipment referred to as “Micro Resistance Welders” is used in industry to process very small intricate parts for medical, electronics, electrical and many other applications. The best place to find an answer to the above question will be on the web. Search for suppliers or users of micro resistance welders.

Weld nugget size and shape are dependent upon the welding parameters and the condition of the parts being spot welded. Electrode size, shape and location on the part can have an effect. The weld schedule which is the power input and force of the electrodes will affect nugget formation. The part material, surface conditions and flatness will contribute to the nugget formation.

Most weld schedules call out a desired nugget size. The welds can be cross sectioned and measured. The most common method is to pull the two welded surfaces apart to expose the nugget. This is performed with a vice, using pliers, hammer and chisel.
The result in graphic form is shown below:

  Nugget Measurement

The nuggets may not be perfect circles. To calculate the nugget size all are calculated using the same simple average of the dimensions as shown. Weld nugget size is the normal specified dimension. Weld nugget area is generally not specified. If desired the area is desired, it can be calculated

Using the area of a circle: A = πR2 or A = πD2/2

In the case of the “C” exhibit above this formula will work. For exhibit “A” or “B” the math becomes complicated. Every nugget can vary in shape and size as suggested by exhibit “A” and “B”, depending upon the weld conditions. Calculation of the weld area for these examples is a mathematics exercise. The possible variations too many for consideration in this blog.

References: RWMA Resistance Welding Manual 4th Edition
                    AWS Standard – C1.1 Recommended Practices for Resistance Welding

It is a common practice to dress resistance welding caps used in robotic and job shop applications. Many dress at breaks or shift changes. In automated operations some dress a very small amount between each part as the line moves. The goal is to maintain a relatively consistent electrode face welding the part. At some point a limit to the material removal is reached and the cap must be changed. The question is:

How much material can be removed before the cap will fail to function?

The assumption is that the dressing removes all surfaces problems and the part is functional. The only consideration is face to waterhole material thickness. Obviously dressing into the water hole is too far. In a nonscientific test observed personally, it was pointed out that the facing thickness is the controlling factor.

When the face thickness is not strong enough to withstand the weld force being applied the electrode face will collapse. Electrode or cap dressing must end before this.  Obviously this face thickness can be affected by the face design of the cap or electrode.

Many end users specify a dressing ring on the cap. Some companies have standard parts with the dressing rings as standards. Some of the rings are limits. Other rings mark the water hole. The actual testing and verification of their functionality is beyond the scope of this blog.

Reference: RWMA – Resistance Welding Manual 4th Edition

This combination of very thin brass a very conductive material to a strong, resistive stainless material is very difficult. The brass due to its conductivity will be slow to heat up. The stainless will heat up and probably conduct heat into the brass. Since the brass is so thin it will suddenly overheat and melt through.  

If any, there is a very small window for success.

Have a Question?

Do you have a question that is not covered in our knowledgebase? Do you have questions regarding the above article? Click here to ask the professor.